Where is Mobile Giving Taking Churches?

Trends in the ways smartphones are being used by consumers to buy goods and services make mobile an increasingly attractive giving channel for churches to explore, particularly given the demographic makeup of the group that uses them the most.

Smartphone usage continues to grow. According to a third quarter 2013 report from consumer research giant Nielsen, some 64.7% of all mobile subscribers in the United States owned a smartphone, up from 62% the previous quarter. “Smartphone ownership also continued to grow among students and recent grads,” Nielsen reports, “as 70% of teens (aged 13-17) and 79% of young adults (aged 18-24) now own smartphones.”
Meanwhile, another potential avenue for mobile giving, the tablet (such as Apple’s iPad), is also expanding its presence. According to Washington, D.C.-based Pew Research Center, a nonpartisan organization that conducts a variety of public opinion, demographic and social science research, the percentage of Americans ages 16 and older who own tablet computers has grown to 35% as of third quarter 2013. Pew also reports that more than half of all households earning $75,000 and up annually now have tablets, up from 25% during the same period in 2012.

Mobile payments
As the numbers of people carrying them grow, mobile devices are increasingly being used by their owners as a means to transfer funds and/or pay for goods and services, as opposed to having to pull out their wallets or write checks.

In a well-publicized example, utilizing a special smartphone application, customers at Starbucks can pay for their treats by simply having their phone screens scanned at the counter. Other manifestations of this trend include Google Wallet, where smartphone users link bank accounts to a Google or Gmail account, enabling them to make purchases by bumping their phone against the cash register, or to transfer money to others by pressing a button.

“I tell all my clients that they need to make a trip to Starbucks, get a cup of coffee, and sit down for 30 minutes and watch how customers pay for their orders,” says Mark Brooks, founding partner and president of the Charis Group, an Atlanta-based fundraising consultant serving Christian ministries.

“And they will see that many of those customers—me included—pay by just pulling out their smartphones and hitting their Starbucks app, never once taking out their billfolds,” Brooks says.

“Churches have generally been slow to adjust,” says Brooks. “We are on our way to becoming a checkless and cashless society, but we still see churches focused solely on passing the offering bucket every Sunday.”
Churches that continue to focus on plate-based giving at the expense of opening up mobile channels run the risk of not developing and tapping the full giving potential of the so-called “millennial generation,” the technologically savvy, adolescent-to-young-adult cohort of the U.S. population that was born between roughly 1980 and 2000.

How Steve Jobs Changed The Church

How many apps do you have on your smart phone or iPad? If you are like the average American the answer is quite a few. Apps, or applications, are those devises that allow ease of use with a smart phone. With the rise of smart phones came the rise of the App Market. That market is poised to continue to grow. Consider the following from a report done by the Application Developers Alliance…

  • 62% of the U.S. online population owned app-capable devices.
  • 74% of those device owners use mobile apps, but only a quarter has paid for an app.
  • Overall, nearly half of the U.S. online population is already using apps.
  • One-third of app users plan to use apps more often and one-third of non-app users say they are likely to begin using apps in the next six months.
  • 52% of respondents said they mostly learn about new apps after hearing about them from friends.
  • 47 % said they download apps because they’re easier to use than a mobile browser, 46 percent do so because apps are the most entertaining way to use their mobile device, and 44 percent said they are the fastest way to get information.

So what does this have to do with your church? Simply this. If you do not have an app for your church you are missing out on one of the key ways to communicate effectively with people today. As Christians we are to be in the market place of our world making sure our message of Hope is communicated. If you lack the primary tools of engagement how can your message effectively reach your world?

Effective churches make connecting with them as easy as possible. Did you see that 47% of app users download apps because they are easier to use than a mobile browser? A good app allows those that attend your church to easily access your website including your giving page.

The multiple pronged approach to effective online communication for churches – Here is our advice to any church that wants to improve its presence in the online community.

It starts with a good website. 84% of all churches have a website in America. However effective websites are continually updated and utilized effectively. If your church website has last years newsletter posted then it is time to rethink your strategy.

“Your website must be mobile friendly. In our consultation with churches about their online platform we state that you need to make sure your website is mobile friendly. Those looking for a church will use their smart phone to search their browser for information. If your online site is not mobile friendly it probably will not be high on the search list as search engines give priority rank to those that have mobile friendly websites. If your website can be found and it is not mobile friendly few will bother to look at it.

Apps are a primary communication tool for connecting your members with the various online offerings of your website. The mobile set up is important for search rank and access to non members but an app is primarily utilized by your membership. Apps can allow your members or regular attendees to more quickly and easily get to all your online sites. With fewer touches they can access all your Social Media sites, get calendar information, listen to last Sunday’s message, receive push notification about important announcements AND give money to your church.

So what does the continued growth of the App Market mean for your church? Brad Phelps a Board member of Application Developers Alliance said, ”The market for mobile apps is growing, and growing fast. Innovation and strong businesses are driving that growth but we are all benefiting from it. Better apps, better services and more opportunity for businesses to thrive is good for us all.” So, with the growth of apps a wise church needs to make sure that they have an app AND that they are using it effectively.

Do you have an app? If not we can help you design one specifically for your church. To find out more go to our website charisgivingsolutions.com/

It’s time you caught up with the 21st century!

Mark Brooks

Founder and President

The Charis Group and Charis Giving Solutions

Offering Plate?

Don’t look now but the offering plate might well be on the way out. A few months back I first wrote about how in the near future offering plates might have devices that would allow donors to simply wave their smart phones in front of them to record their gift. Some readers were sketical, some thought the idea would destroy the sanctity of the offering and others wanted to know more. Ready or not the future is here!

This past week newspapers across the country reported that more than a dozen big merchants like Wal-Mart are working to develop mobile payment networks. In part they are doing this to challlenge Google’s similar mobile payment plan called Google Wallet. The concept is to allow consumers to pay for their purchases by using their smartphones. Truly the wave of the future is that smartphones will replace wallets.

The Wall Street Journal stated about this issue, “While few shoppers use their phones as mobile-payment devices, industry executives are convinced that consumers eventually will be just as comfortable buying with their phones as they now are when using credit cards and debit cards.”

Consider these facts as stated in the same article…

  • Mobile-payment transactions are expected to surge to an estimated $600 billion world-wide by 2016, up from $172 billion this year.
  • 87% of Americans have a mobile phone.
  • 50% of those phones are smartphones.

Clearly we are on the cusp of a revolutionary change in how commerce takes place.

So, what about the churhes response to this? Like most things the church is behind the times. In 2011 it was found that only 14% of US churches offered online giving. We are utilizing a collection tool that came on the scene fully around 1900. Weekly we are attemting to fund our minstries with tools that few of our donors are using, checks and cash. If the church doesn’t change its methods of collection it runs the risk of losing money.

To meet the future that is now upon us the church must…

  • Rethink their views on how to take up the offering.The Bible doesn’t tell us how to give it simply teaches that we are to give.
  • Get over their fear of anything new. Technology is not evil especially if it is used to further the Gospel.
  • Give members options in how and when they can give. Few carry a checkbook with them any longer and most don’t carry cash.
  • Build NOW the platforms for the future of giving. very church should have online giving set up, an app to allow members easy access to their site and a website that is mobile friendly.
  • Develop a plan of implementation to meet the rise of technology. One thing is for sure, we cannot continue to do business as usual if we want to see our giving stay steady or increase.

One of my favorite stories about the effectiveness of online giving comes from a client church whose pastor told me, “Online giving has helped us even out our summer giving. We no longer have the huge swings of donations when people are on vacation. Fifty percent of what we take in weekly comes from online giving. Online giving has taken the panic out of Monday morning!” This churches annual budget is around $250K. If a church this size can see the necessity of operating with 21st century technology any church can and should do the same.

Offering plates with smartphone readers might be a few years off. However online commerce is already here and being successfully used by churches across the country. It is easy and cost effective to set up. If your church does not have online giving you are missing out on an opportunity to increase your donations. Get started today assuring your church is in the 21st century of commerce.

Mark Brooks

Founder and President

The Charis Group and Charis Giving Solutions

Sorry Pastor, I forgot My Checkbook

This Sunday if your members forget to bring their checkbook to church with them could they still tithe to your church? If they are away on holiday does their gift to your church show up in your offering plate? For 86% of US churches the answer is no.

Over the past decade online bill payment has increased by 800%. Paper check usage has declined from 61% of all payments in 2000 to just 26% in 2010. In 2011 the number of checks processed by the Federal Reserve fell at its steepest rate yet, a third of the volume processed 20 years ago. Many now say that paper checks will soon be a thing of the past. Why is it then that only 14% of US churches offer online giving!

Obviously 84% of US churches don’t see online giving as that big of a deal. In my discussions with Christian leaders about this trend I have found a variety of reasons why churches are pushing back against online giving. This post is the first part in dealing with those objections. Let’s look at two of the most common objections churches have to online giving.

Online giving is only a fraction of the total amount a church takes in. One blog posted the following about online giving…

“The slice of the online pie is still a sliver. On average, online donations accounted for 6.3 percent of overall fundraising. Among small organizations (budgets of less than $1 million), the average was slightly higher, at 8.7 percent; among medium organizations (budgets of $1 million to $10 million), it was a tad lower, at 6 percent. This underscores a simple truth: Online giving remains a sliver of the overall pie for organizations.”

First of all the data used from the above quote came not from a scientific survey but an opinion poll. Our experience and findings are that online giving is rising so fast that most professional pollsters are not even tracking the data. Another reason why some churches are not seeing a a large percentage of giving come from online giving is that they do not properly use the tool. If you use the tool of online giving correctly the amount you take in as a percentage of all gifts will rise.

Recently one of my clients emailed me about the online campaign we have been running and said, “The online giving in March was 46k and in April it was 72k – 57% increase in one month, we are on the right track, but need to continue to take it up. We are promoting online giving weekly.” That is the key. I have several clients right now that are seeing online giving represent between 30% to 50% of their total gifts.

Another of the biggest objections to online giving is the belief that online giving does not increase total gifts to the church. Again listen to what a blog post said about this, “What isn’t clear is whether these percentages represent new dollars the organizations otherwise wouldn’t have received, thus making the overall pie grow. If they are new, that’s encouraging. The likelier conclusion, though, is that some of those dollars were given by current donors who would have given anyway, but found the online giving option more convenient.”

Why set up something that will not net you an increase in giving? After all online giving does cost you a fractional percentage fee to the processing companies that allow the ease of use of this new tool. So, unless online giving increases your giving why bother? Online giving does indeed increase your total gifts. One reason why this is true is that online giving allows for recurring gifts to be set up. This allows for consistency in giving and thus brings an increase in giving.

A pastor of a small midwestern church told me this week, “Our summer giving used to really decline causing us all kinds of stress on Monday mornings. We made a concerted effort at the start of the summer to push for online recurring giving. In the past when someone went on vacation they never made up that missed offering. Now their gift comes in through online giving. Our giving this summer has stayed consistent taking the panic out of Monday morning!”

I am hearing this same story from numerous sources. So while it might be that your donors simply use online giving because it is convenient that convenience will build consistency. Consistency builds an increase in giving. Even if that only represents an increase of less than 10%, online giving would more than pay for itself. I believe that as online giving catches on and more professional studies are done we will see that it does increase giving.

One way to see online giving help increase the total amount you bring in is to use the tool. Too many churches simply set up online giving and never advertise its benefits. This is one reason why we help churches build Apps that make it easy for members to give online as well as set up websites to be Mobile friendly.

You have to work at getting people to sign up for online giving. Remember the quote above about the church that saw online giving increase by 57% in one month? Look at this video they put together that emphasized online giving www.youtube.com/watch?v=9BVGSitOwNQ&feature=plcp 

It is time the church wakes up and realizes that society is online and doing commerce online. Setting up online giving not only makes you current with the times it will increase your offerings! If you are not online you are behind. Contact us today to see how easy and affordable it is to set up online giving.

Mark Brooks

Founder and President

The Charis Group

I Forgot My Checkbook Part 2

On Friday December 30th as 2011 was winding down I wanted to get our tithe check into my church before the year ended. Amazingly we could not find any checks in our house. We only write a few checks a month and two of those are to our church. I told my wife to just go to our churches website and pay our tithe online. My church, which runs almost 1,000 in attendance with a nearly $2 million dollar annual budget does not have online giving! Now what do I do? We went to our bank, had a cashiers check made out and drove to the church office before they closed to get our tithe in. How many people would have just forgotten the whole thing?

What amazed me was when I went in to give the check to the financial secretary I commented about our trying to give online. She commented, “We tried that a couple of years ago but our members really did not like it.” She gave one of the biggest objections to online giving that I commonly hear. We tried online giving and it did not work. The fault lies not with online giving but with the church and how they implemented online giving.

The timing was not right. We tried it a couple of years ago in the technological age we live in is like saying you tried it a decade ago. Things are changing so fast that it is often difficult to keep up. I read a blogger’s post the other day where he said that the tools he was using today in his business did not exist five years ago. What did not gain traction two years ago might be wildly accepted now. Interestingly studies have shown that two thirds of the churches offering online giving have offered it for only two years or less.

Online bill payment has surged in just the last few years. In fact online giving to charities has increased 13% year over year. Every nonprofit sector has seen double digit online fundraising growth since 2009. If you tried online giving a couple of years ago it is time to try it again!

The tool was not properly used. This is the second and in all probability the real reason a churches attempts at online giving does not succeed. Online giving is a tool. Like any tool left unused or improperly used it does not fulfill its intended purpose. You cannot simply set up online giving and hope that your members find it. They won’t. You have to work at it. Here are two quotes from church leaders that I am working with about their online giving.

“Our online giving in March was 46k and in April it was 72k – 57% increase in one month, we are on the right track, but need to continue to take it up. We are promoting online giving weekly.” I underlined that last quote as that is the key!

Recently one of my clients emailed me about the online campaign we have been running and said, “The online giving in March was 46k and in April it was 72k – 57% increase in one month, we are on the right track, but need to continue to take it up. We are promoting online giving weekly.” That is the key. I have several clients right now that are seeing online giving represent between 30% to 50% of their total gifts.

A pastor in a small church commented to me, “We generally take in about $4,500 a week. In the summer there were times where we would have an offering of less than $1,000. As we moved into summer we began an initiative to get our members to set up recurring giving through our online portal. Now 50% of our giving comes online and our offerings this summer have stayed consistent. It has taken away the Monday morning panic!” Again notice what I underlined. They talked about online giving from the platform and worked to sign people up.

Why set up something that will not net you an increase in giving? After all online giving does cost you a fractional percentage fee to the processing companies that allow the ease of use of this new tool. So, unless online giving increases your giving why bother? Online giving does indeed increase your total gifts. One reason why this is true is that online giving allows for recurring gifts to be set up. This allows for consistency in giving and thus brings an increase in giving.

One of the major keys to successfully implementing online giving is to continually keep it in front of your congregation. 

I have a small shed attached to our house. In that shed I have a lot of yard and garden tools plus my lawn mower. Those tools help us keep our lawn in order. Yet if I did not use those tools properly the fault is not with the tool but with me. The same analogy is true for the church and online giving. Properly used this tool can and will help increase your giving. Would you like to have the Monday morning panic removed from your life? Online giving can do that for you.

Mark Brooks

Founder and President

The Charis Group

Smartphone Churches?

I remember the first cell phone I ever saw. It was about as big as a loaf of bread! I was so envious of my pastor friend who had the ability to be in instant contact with his church. Though each call cost an arm and a leg he could still be accessible even when he was traveling. I wanted one! I thought I needed one and I just had to have one. The problem was getting the Finance Committee of my church to see this not as a toy but as a necessary means of communication. Ultimately we purchased a mobile phone and did use it.

At the time if you would have told us that a day would come when people would send communications to one another on their phone, do their calendar and scheduling on their phone and even pay their bills on their phone no one would have believed you. Then if you would have stated that the phone would fit in your pocket they would have really thought you were completely nuts. Fast forward twenty plus years and the phone in your pocket has more power and storage than the early computers that took up a whole room. Times have changed.

We live in the Smartphone Era. It has changed the way we do everything. From email, to bill pay to finding the closest Starbucks we do everything with our phones. Oh, and we still talk to people on them too.

Since smartphones are the predominate tool for communications today wouldn’t it be smart for churches to have a Smartphone Strategy? Smart churches are prepared for the smartphone era. Here is my Smartphone Strategy recommendations…

Have an up to date web site that is not only informational but interactive. Smart churches have moved away from their websites simply being an extension of the Sunday morning bulletin and instead actually being a workable site that members continuously engage in and go to. How up to date and useful is your site?

Make sure your church website is set up for mobile viewing. More and more people are accessing the Web through their smartphones and iPads. If your site is not mobile friendly they will not stay long on the site. Also, if it is not mobile friendly search engines will not list your church high on a search of churches in your area. Is your site mobile?

Set up Social Media sites to tell the story of your church. Facebook is the front porch of America. Your church can easily tell the story of what you are doing through Social Media sites like Facebook and Twitter. What is more they are free tools to get your message out. Are you using Social Media effectively to tell your story?

Have an App that makes connecting to all your platforms easy. With the rise of the smartphone comes the rise of Apps which is short for applications. An App allows your members to easily connect with all your sites. A good app also allows you to communicate more effectively at short notice with your members. Does your church have a workable App?

Have an online giving platform. The world is moving away from cash and checks. More and more people are using their smartphones to purchase products and pay bills. Online giving is on the rise. Before long the traditional offering plate will be a thing of the past. The future of online giving is now not in the future. Do you have online giving set up?

I wish I could say that the church is on the cutting edge of all this. The reality is that we are behind. Only 14% of churches in America for instance offer online giving. Continually when I talk to churches about this need I get that glassed over look. We are behind and desperately need to catch up if we are to have any chance to reverse the decline in giving to the church in America.

The Smartphone Era is here. Is your church set up to connect with the people of this era? Smart churches are prepared for the smartphone era. Are you?

Mark Brooks

Founder and President

The Charis Group